Article

Scarlet Macaws Buried in a New Mexico Great House

By Weird Burial Stories Editorial Desk · 2026-09-27

Room 38 at Pueblo Bonito, built in the ninth century, held twelve scarlet macaw skeletons in a layer of guano. Two more macaws were buried in hollows in the corners of the floor.

Room 38 at Pueblo Bonito, in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, was built in the ninth century. It held the skeletons of twelve scarlet macaws in a layer of guano about 25 centimeters thick, and two more macaws were buried in hollows dug into the southeastern and southwestern corners of the floor. Thirty macaws have been found at Pueblo Bonito, fourteen of them in that one room, and a 2018 DNA study of fourteen birds from Chaco Canyon and the Mimbres region points to a breeding center that no one has found.

The room

Pueblo Bonito is the largest of the Chacoan great houses. Adam S. Watson, Stephen Plog, and their colleagues, in a 2015 paper in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, describe it as a pueblo of about 650 rooms, built in several phases. Chaco Canyon, they write, had multistoried great houses from the ninth through the early twelfth centuries. Room 38 sits in the northern section. It is the largest room there, and it was built in the ninth century.

The same paper is precise about the birds. "These included the skeletons of 12 scarlet macaws imbedded in a 25-cm-thick layer of bird guano. Two additional macaws were buried in hollows dug in the southeastern and southwestern corners of the floor." A later faunal analysis gives a minimum of fourteen scarlet macaws from the room. Eleven of them were sampled for radiocarbon dating. An American Museum of Natural History news release, carried by EurekAlert, gives the same counts in a single sentence: "The remains of 30 macaws have been found in Pueblo Bonito, including 14 in a single structure: Room 38." The paper's wider count is thirty from Pueblo Bonito out of thirty-five scarlet macaw skeletons recovered in Chaco Canyon. On the strength of the guano, the release calls Room 38 "likely a sort of aviary." The guano shows that birds were kept in the room, not only buried there. The two in the floor hollows are the burials.

The Death Glossary uses "grave goods" for objects placed with the dead. These macaws are not goods in a human coffin. They are the dead themselves, set into the floor of a room that also held their droppings. A dog buried in the same grave as two people, near Bonn and far earlier, is the other animal burial in this week's archive: the Bonn-Oberkassel dogs.

Kept there, not bred there

The 2015 paper is careful about breeding, and its evidence points the other way. The number of macaws in one room, along with the guano, has no parallel in the northern Southwest, the authors write, yet faunal analysts had concluded that macaws were not bred at Pueblo Bonito or anywhere else in the northern Southwest. Of thirty-four Chaco macaws studied earlier by Lyndon Hargrave, only one may have reached breeding age. No nestlings and no juveniles under four months old were found. No breeding pens and no macaw eggshells have been reported from Bonito. Paquimé, in northern Mexico, about 630 kilometers to the south, offers the contrast: hundreds of macaws, pens, and eggshells. Room 38 was a place where birds were kept and, in two cases, buried. According to this paper, it was not a hatchery.

The dates on the sampled bones fall within the Chacoan centuries, and most of them come before the great surge of building that archaeologists call the Chaco florescence, about AD 1040 to 1110. Twelve of the fourteen sampled macaws are older than that peak. One cluster, four from Room 38 and two from Room 78, has ranges between AD 885 and 990. A second cluster, all from Room 38, falls between AD 970 and 1035. The news release says the birds were brought from Mesoamerica beginning in the early tenth century. The paper's point is about chronology: the macaws were acquired while the canyon's hierarchy was already taking shape, not only when its architecture was at its height. Scarlet macaws do not live in New Mexico. Their historic range, the paper says, is the humid forest of tropical America. Bringing a live bird to Chaco meant a long chain of procurement. The paper does not claim that every skeleton was a sacrifice. It treats the birds as markers of status and as evidence of a network.

The breeding center that is still missing

A later study, reported by Smithsonian Magazine on 13 August 2018, asked where the birds had been born. Katherine J. Wu's article says a team led by Richard George, then at Pennsylvania State University, studied the bones of fourteen scarlet macaws from five sites in Chaco Canyon and the Mimbres region of New Mexico. The magazine's sentence is the one worth keeping: they "analyzed the bones of 14 scarlet macaws recovered from five sites in Chaco Canyon and the Mimbres region of New Mexico." The tool was mitochondrial DNA, which passes from mothers to their offspring. The fourteen birds were extremely similar. The magazine says it appeared that 71 percent of them probably shared a maternal lineage.

That result does not fit a story in which each bird was captured separately in the tropics. Macaws range widely. Related mothers, turning up in bird after bird, suggest a breeding group. The magazine says the researchers turned their attention to a northern breeding center, one that had been doubted. Paquimé has an aviary and more than 300 macaws, but Paquimé's peak came later, about 1250 to 1450, while Chaco's peak was about 850 to 1150. Radiocarbon dates place the studied birds in the Chacoan era. The New Mexican macaws, the article says, came from an older site farther north that has not been found. The researchers put that center somewhere in the North American Southwest or northwestern Mexico, and they do not name a spot. George is quoted as saying it was probably small, given how inbred the Chaco and Mimbres birds seem to be.

The two findings sit next to each other without canceling each other out. Room 38 held living birds, as the guano shows, and two of them were buried in the floor. The 2015 paper says they were not bred in that room. The 2018 study, as Smithsonian reports it, says the birds' mothers came from a breeding population somewhere else, still undiscovered. The hollows in the corners are the burial. The missing aviary is a conclusion drawn from genetics, not a room anyone has excavated.

Sources