The Viking Buried Sitting Up at Birka
At Birka, grave Bj 581 was a log chamber in which Hjalmar Stolpe read the body as sitting, with a bag of gaming pieces in the lap and two horses at the edge. The person was biologically female. Whether that makes a warrior is still debated.
Grave Bj 581 at Birka was a log-built chamber, excavated by Hjalmar Stolpe in 1878, in which he interpreted the body as sitting up, with a bag of gaming pieces in its lap and two horses on a platform at the edge of the chamber. Genomic work published in 2017 showed that the person was biologically female, and the reading of the grave as a warrior's is still debated.
The chamber
Birka stood on the island of Björkö in Lake Mälaren. The 2019 reassessment in Antiquity, by Neil Price, Charlotte Hedenstierna-Jonson, and their colleagues, calls it the first urban center in what is now Sweden. Stolpe excavated about 1,100 of the mounds. Bj 581 lay outside the northern gate of the hillfort and was the westernmost grave on the site.
The online supplement to that paper describes the chamber. It was underground and built of logs, and it measured 3.45 by 1.75 meters and 1.8 meters deep. Inside, the supplement says, "an individual had been interred in what the excavator Hjalmar Stolpe interpreted as a sitting position, perhaps on a low chair or stool." Seated burials turn up in several of the Birka chambers. Later catalogues followed Stolpe's reading of this one. It is his interpretation of the position. The supplement does not say that a chair was found.
The same paragraph records a second suggestion, and it is only that, a suggestion. Anneli Sundkvist has proposed that the person may not have sat on a chair at all, but perched on a saddle. The supplement marks this as a personal communication. A saddle is not something the text says was recovered. It is another way of picturing a body that Stolpe did not find lying flat.
Another body kept upright, on a different authority and about seven hundred years later, is Ben Jonson, buried on his feet in Westminster Abbey. The two graves do not explain each other. In both, the recorded posture is the strange fact.
What was placed with the body
The 2019 paper describes the grave in a single sentence worth keeping whole: two horses, one of them bridled for riding, laid out on a platform at the edge of the chamber, and "a bag of gaming pieces was placed in the person's lap and a gaming board was propped up beside them." The supplement goes into more detail. The platform sat at the foot of the chamber, raised 0.6 meters above the floor. On it lay a stallion and a mare, one of them bridled. Their legs were folded beneath them. Four ice crampons were found for the hooves. The authors ask, in parentheses, whether that points to a winter burial or to the dead heading somewhere colder. They leave the question unanswered. This article will leave it unanswered too.
The gaming set was complete. The supplement counts 28 pieces, including a king piece marked with an iron nail, bundled into a bag with three antler dice, a polyhedral weight, and two spheroid weights, all held in the lap. What looks like an iron-framed gaming board was leaned up beside the body. The Death Glossary uses "grave goods" for objects buried with the dead. These were placed against the body, not scattered through the fill.
Weapons surrounded the person. The supplement lists a sword, a broad-axe, a fighting knife, two spears, two shields, and a quiver of 25 arrows. The main paper says the burial had long been published as a high-status warrior grave, and that the assumption of a male body started with Stolpe's notes. Nobody disputes the objects. What they prove about the person's life is the argument.
PBS, on its Secrets of the Dead page for the episode "Viking Warrior Queen," says that in 1878 Stolpe and his team found a grave with two horses buried under a large block of granite. The supplement is more precise about that stone, and its account is the one followed here. No mound was visible. The grave appeared as a shallow dip, where the roof had collapsed. The marker was a granite boulder more than four meters long, which had sunk into the chamber. Stolpe's 1879 report, quoted in the supplement, says the stone was so big that he had to blast it apart in order to dig.
A fragment of an Arab silver dirham, of Nasr ibn Ahmad, from the reign of al-Muktadir (AD 913 to 933), lay in the burial. The supplement says the artifacts also support a mid-tenth-century date on typological grounds.
Female, and the warrior question
The supplement states the genomic result plainly. The occupant of the grave, long assumed to be male, had been shown to be biologically female, using a chromosomal definition of sex. The burial was excavated in 1878 and had been interpreted ever since as that of a high-status warrior. The main paper says the 2017 study in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology presented the ancient DNA, building on earlier osteological work, and that the body was buried alone. PBS reports the same result about sex in simpler terms: two X chromosomes and no Y chromosome.
The authors of the 2019 paper argue for a warrior reading. They also include the caution that belongs in any article about burial. Objects buried with the dead were not necessarily that person's belongings, or a record of what they did in life. They ask, in their own words, whether the occupant can be proved to have been a warrior, and they answer that it depends on definitions. Non-functional weapons, and weapons buried with children who could never have used them, exist in other early medieval cemeteries. Their own conclusion is that Bj 581 was the grave of a woman who lived as a professional warrior. Other readers, they note, may reach different conclusions. In their view, the integrity of the grave and the biological sex are secure. The identity is not a closed question.
This article sticks to the burial. The chamber, the sitting position as Stolpe read it, the bag in the lap, the two horses, and a biologically female skeleton are what the sources describe. The warrior title is the debate those sources are having. A reading of the textiles as the dress of a cavalry commander is part of that same argument, and it is not repeated here as a finding.
Stolpe believed the body was sitting. The saddle is a later guess. The horses lay at the edge, one of them bridled. The gaming pieces were in the lap. The rest is an argument about what a grave is allowed to mean.
For the wider Viking Age on screen, Curiosity Stream (affiliate link) carries history documentaries. Watch them the way this article reads Bj 581: the grave goods are the evidence, and the narration is one interpretation of them.
Sources
- Neil Price, Charlotte Hedenstierna-Jonson, and colleagues, "Viking warrior women? Reassessing Birka chamber grave Bj.581," Antiquity 93, no. 367 (2019). The chamber grave, the two horses with one bridled, the gaming pieces in the lap, the 1878 excavation, the 2017 genomic result, and the authors' own argument that a warrior reading is the best fit and still a matter of definition. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/article/viking-warrior-women-reassessing-birka-chamber-grave-bj581/7CC691F69FAE51DDE905D27E049FADCD
- Online supplement to that paper. The log chamber of 3.45 by 1.75 metres and 1.8 metres deep, Stolpe's sitting position, the saddle suggestion, the stallion and mare, the 28 gaming pieces, the weapons, the granite boulder, and the dirham. https://static.cambridge.org/content/id/urn:cambridge.org:id:article:S0003598X18002582/resource/name/S0003598X18002582sup001.pdf
- PBS, Secrets of the Dead, "Viking Warrior Queen." The 1878 find of a grave with two horses beneath a granite block, and the report of two X chromosomes and no Y chromosome. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/secrets/viking-warrior-queen/5180/