The Ghost Turnip and Stingy Jack
The jack-o'-lantern in the National Museum of Ireland is a turnip, or rather a plaster cast of one, given in 1943 by a Donegal teacher. The name is older than the pumpkin. The story of Stingy Jack is a tale, not a date.
In 1943 the National Museum of Ireland received a turnip lantern from Rois Ní Braonáin, a schoolteacher near Fintown, County Donegal. She said it was the kind that had always been made in that area around 1900. The original was close to crumbling. What the museum put on display is a plaster-cast model, made and painted by the museum artist Eileen Barnes. The catalogue number on the museum's own page is F1943.350. Candles went inside. The lanterns were used to frighten people on the night of 31 October. The museum's line on the pumpkin is brief: it is "an American development of this Irish tradition." That is an object with a donor, a parish, and a year. It makes a better starting point than a legend.
What the museum is willing to say
The museum also tells the folktale, and it tells it as a folktale. The term jack-o'-lantern, it says, comes from the story of Jack, "welcome neither in Heaven or Hell," doomed to wander the countryside with nothing but a lantern to light his way. It sends readers to dúchas.ie for more versions. It does not date the story, and it does not call it ancient. A plaster turnip and a wandering man are two very different kinds of evidence, sitting on the same webpage, and the webpage keeps them straight. The turnip is accessioned. Jack is a name in a story.
Encyclopaedia Britannica's Halloween entry tells one Irish version at length, and its verbs are the verbs of fiction. Jack invites the Devil for a drink and talks him into turning into a coin to pay for it. Jack puts the coin in his pocket next to a silver cross, which traps him. The Devil is let go only after he promises to leave Jack alone for a year and not to claim his soul. A year later Jack tricks him into climbing a tree for fruit and carves a cross in the trunk. He lets him down in exchange for a ten-year reprieve. When Jack dies, neither heaven nor hell will have him. He is handed a glowing coal, sets it inside a hollowed turnip, and becomes Jack of the Lantern. Britannica then says the carving of turnips, and later pumpkins, was believed to help guide or ward off wandering spirits. That last sentence describes a belief about a practice. The plot before it is "the tale." The entry gives no year of origin. Other versions exist. Treating Stingy Jack as history would be a category mistake. The museum's turnip is the history.
On the Isle of Man the turnip never gave up its night. Children still carve them for Hop-tu-Naa and sing at the doors. That living custom, along with the debate over whether the night was a Celtic New Year, is covered in Hop-tu-Naa. The Donegal lantern in Dublin is the museum's proof that the same vegetable served as a Halloween light on the Irish mainland around 1900, in at least one district, and that a teacher thought it worth saving.
The word, before the vegetable
The name is older than both the museum's turnip and the American pumpkin, and it did not begin as a face. Etymonline, drawing on the historical record of English, says "Jack with the lanthorn" was a name in the 1650s for the ignis fatuus, the will-o'-the-wisp, the light over the marsh. The shorter forms jack-o-lantern and jack-a-lantern are in use by 1750. The extension to a lantern made from a carved pumpkin is recorded by 1828 in American English, as "Jack-o-lanthorn." So for more than a century and a half, the spooky phrase named a light on a bog before it ever named a gourd on a porch. The Death Glossary is where this site defines an interment. A jack-o'-lantern is not an interment. It is a light the living carry. The bog light and the carved root share a name. They do not share a grave.
Britannica's Samhain entry is the place to see the origin claim at its weakest. It is possible, the entry says, that wearing masks and carving scary faces into turnips, which became pumpkins in the United States, grew out of Samhain customs. "It is possible" is the entire claim. The same entry says it is unclear which parts of Samhain lived on in later Allhallowtide tradition, and that very little about ancient Samhain can be stated with certainty because the evidence is sparse. Smithsonian and other popular retellings sometimes leave out the "possible." The reference book keeps it in. Hutton's argument that the feast-of-the-dead story is first recorded in the 19th century is the one already laid out in Samhain and All Hallows. A Donegal turnip from around 1900 cannot settle a question about the Iron Age. What it can settle is what a lantern looked like in Fintown within the living memory of the woman who gave it to the museum.
A cast, a tale, and a porch
The object to trust is the cast: F1943.350, painted by Eileen Barnes, after a lantern Rois Ní Braonáin said was the local type around 1900, used with a candle to frighten people on 31 October. The tale to enjoy, and not to footnote as an event, is Stingy Jack, in the version Britannica prints and in the shorter version on the museum label. The word to date is the will-o'-the-wisp of the 1650s, along with the carved pumpkin of 1828 American English. The Samhain link is a possibility that Britannica will not promote. That is a complete account of a vegetable. The pumpkin on a modern porch is the American development the museum has already named. The turnip is what that development grew out of, in the only sense a catalogue can prove: a teacher in Donegal still knew how to make one, and she sent it to Dublin before it turned to dust. Jack's one borrowed light still walks the streets every 31 October, now as pumpkins.
Sources
- National Museum of Ireland, "Ghost turnip," Irish Folklife collection, NMI F1943.350. Rois Ní Braonáin, Fintown, the 1943 gift, the type made around 1900, Eileen Barnes's cast, candles on 31 October, the pumpkin as an American development, and Jack as a folktale. https://www.museum.ie/en-IE/Collections-Research/Collection/Top-things-to-see-in-the-Irish-Folklife-Collection/Artefact/Ghost-turnip/b202e8ea-0728-4b3d-b0f1-82660fe45ce9
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Halloween." The Stingy Jack tale, the coal in the turnip, and the belief that carved vegetables guided or warded off spirits. Allhallowtide as 31 October, 1 November, and 2 November. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Halloween
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Samhain." Carved turnip faces "possibly" developed from Samhain customs; the evidence for ancient practice is sparse. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Samhain
- Online Etymology Dictionary, "jack-o'-lantern." "Jack with the lanthorn" in the 1650s for the ignis fatuus; the carved-pumpkin sense by 1828 in American English. https://www.etymonline.com/word/jack-o%27-lantern
- Ronald Hutton, "The Celtic New Year and Feast of the Dead," Folklore 135, no. 1 (2024). Why the feast-of-the-dead origin story is not a medieval record. https://core.ac.uk/download/710434235.pdf