Article

The New England Vampire Panic: JB-55 and Mercy Brown

By Weird Burial Stories Editorial Desk · 2026-09-27

In 1990 a Connecticut gravel pit yielded a coffin lid tacked JB-55 and a skeleton rearranged after death. In 2019 a military DNA lab pointed to a man named John Barber, and called the name putative. In 1892, in Exeter, Rhode Island, the same fear had a name, a newspaper, and a date.

New England's vampire panic was a theory of contagion from before the countryside believed in germs. Consumption, the old name for tuberculosis, moved through a family and looked, to the people watching, like the dead feeding on the living. Two files hold the history. One is archaeological: an unmarked burial ground at a sand and gravel works in Griswold, Connecticut, and a coffin lid with brass tacks that spelled JB-55. The other is a year in the newspapers: Exeter, Rhode Island, 1892, and Mercy Lena Brown. The Rhode Island Historical Society calls her the last person in New England exhumed as a suspected vampire. Neither file is a novel. Both are arguments about what the living did to a grave because they were afraid of a disease.

The coffin lid in the gravel

The careful account is the 2019 paper in Genes by Jennifer Daniels-Higginbotham and colleagues at the Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory. In 1990 an unmarked cemetery from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries was excavated in Griswold after skeletal remains turned up during sand and gravel work. The paper counts twenty-seven burials. Smithsonian Magazine, in Abigail Tucker's 2012 feature, says children playing near the hillside mine found the first graves, and that one boy carried a skull home to his mother. Tucker counts twenty-nine burials. The numbers disagree. The peer-reviewed count is twenty-seven. The children's discovery comes from Tucker's reporting, and it explains why the ground was first opened as a possible crime scene, before Nick Bellantoni, who was then Connecticut's state archaeologist, dated the bones to a colonial farm cemetery.

One grave stood apart from the others. Brass tacks on the coffin lid spelled JB-55, which the Genes paper reads as initials plus an age at death of 55. The hardware, screws and copper dowel hinges, dates the coffin to the early nineteenth century. After death, the skull and the thighbones had been rearranged into a skull-and-crossbones. The ribs showed lesions that the authors call consistent with a chronic lung infection, possibly tuberculosis. The paper's own hypothesis, following an earlier study by Sledzik and Bellantoni, is that if no heart was left to burn, the remedy was to rearrange the bones. That is an interpretation of a practice. The rearrangement itself is what the excavators found.

In 2019 the Armed Forces lab went back to the bones. A Y-chromosome profile, checked against a public surname project, came up with its closest matches in men named Barber. Historical records led the authors to a death notice for a John Barber whose son Nathan was buried in Griswold in 1826, and they write that Nathan's description fits a nearby burial marked NB-13. The paper's title calls the identification putative. The abstract then says the identity "has been revealed." Both sentences sit in the same document. The Department of Defense news service, covering the announcement at the National Museum of Health and Medicine, quotes the senior analyst Jennifer Higginbotham: "Our research points to a male named John Barber." "Points to" is the right verb. A Y-chromosome match gives a surname, not a fingerprint, and the authors say as much with the word they chose for the title.

The paper describes the fear around Jewett City, a borough of Griswold, as a mid-nineteenth-century belief that the dead rose and drained their surviving relatives, and that consumption was the visible sign of that feeding. Tucker's Smithsonian piece is the longer portrait of how that belief played out across rural New England. It is also the source of the five-years-after-death detail: Bellantoni told her the beheading and the other damage looked to him like a disturbance about five years after death. The 2019 paper does not repeat that interval. It says only that the bones were rearranged after death. The interval is a recollection in a magazine, not a finding of the DNA study.

Exeter, 1892

Mercy Lena Brown is the case that comes with a calendar. The Rhode Island Historical Society's account, by Jennifer L. Galpern, says she was born in Exeter in 1872, and that family and friends called her Lena. Her mother, Mary Eliza, died of consumption on 8 December 1883. Her sister Mary Olive, a dressmaker of about twenty, died on 6 June 1884. Lena's own illness was the "galloping" kind. She died on 17 January 1892. Her brother Edwin had been ill for years, had tried Colorado Springs, and came home after her death in worse shape. Galpern writes that frightened neighbors pleaded with their father, George Brown, to dig up the women's bodies, find out which one was to blame, and stop whatever was taking Edwin.

Smithsonian fills in the morning. On 17 March 1892 a group of men exhumed the bodies. The family doctor and a correspondent from the Providence Journal looked on. George stayed away. The mother and the sister, dead for years, were almost nothing but bone. Lena, dead for two months over the winter, was not. The correspondent wrote that the heart and liver were removed, and that when the heart was cut open it held clotted, decomposed blood. The doctor, Tucker reports, said once again that the lungs showed tuberculosis. The villagers burned the heart and liver. Edwin was given the ashes. They did not save him. Galpern dates his death to 2 May 1892. Tucker, without giving the exact day, says he died less than two months after the exhumation. The two accounts agree on the order of events. The Society's date is the precise one.

Galpern is also the source of the "last" claim: Mercy was the last person in New England exhumed as a suspected vampire. The same essay declines a neat ending. Consumption went on taking George Brown's children after Edwin. The panic did not stop the disease. All it did was open a grave. A haunted cemetery in the later sense is often a tour, and Chestnut Hill in Exeter became one. The events of 1892 are a public health disaster that the neighbors read as a problem in the ground.

What the two graves share

JB-55 and Mercy Brown are not the same ritual. One is a rearranged skeleton in a Connecticut farm plot, identified only as far as a surname hypothesis. The other is a documented exhumation, with a doctor, a newspaper, and a father who gave his permission and kept away. What they have in common is the disease and the belief that destroying the suspected corpse would protect the living. Polish graves with sickles belong to a different century and involve a different object, and the archaeologists there are just as cautious about the vampire label: Drawsko and Pień. The English medieval pit at Wharram Percy is the older relative, argued from cut marks and isotopes rather than from a newspaper.

The disputed points should stay disputed. John Barber is a putative name, according to the paper's title, even though the abstract sounds surer. The burial count is twenty-seven in Genes and twenty-nine in Smithsonian. Mercy's exhumation is not a folktale: the Providence Journal was in the churchyard, and the Historical Society cites the death records. The belief got the mechanism wrong. Tuberculosis does not need a revenant. The families buried their dead anyway, and then, in Exeter, buried them a second time.

Sources