The Village That Feared Its Dead Would Walk
In a deserted Yorkshire village, archaeologists found 137 burnt and broken bones from at least ten medieval people, buried in a pit. The team ruled out outsiders and famine cannibalism. The reading they kept is that the living were trying to stop the dead from walking.
Wharram Percy is a deserted medieval village in North Yorkshire, and English Heritage looks after what remains of it. Inside the settlement, not in the churchyard, excavators found a pit full of human bone. A team from Historic England and the University of Southampton counted 137 bones from at least ten people, dated to the eleventh through the fourteenth centuries. Many of the bones had been burned. Some had been broken on purpose after death. The researchers' best explanation is that the villagers were trying to keep the dead from getting up. Simon Mays, the human skeletal biologist at Historic England who led the work, built the caution right into his sentence. "If we are right, then this is the first good archaeological evidence we have for this practice."
Three explanations, tested in order
The study was published on 3 April 2017 in the Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. The University of Southampton's account of it, written with the team, is the public record of what they tested. The first theory was that these people were outsiders, handled strangely because they did not come from the village. Alistair Pike, professor of archaeological sciences at Southampton, led the isotope work. Strontium in tooth enamel records the geology a person lived on while their teeth were forming in childhood. At Wharram Percy the ratios matched the local geology. Pike's conclusion, in the university's release, is that these people grew up close to where they were buried, possibly in the village itself. The outsider theory fell apart. That surprised the team. They had wondered whether unusual treatment pointed to a foreign body.
The second theory was hunger. Famines were common in medieval England, and a pit of broken bones can look like butchery. But the marks were not where butchery marks usually are. In cannibalism, knife cuts gather around the major muscle attachments and the large joints. At Wharram Percy the cuts were mostly on the head and neck. The university's summary says the famine explanation did not fit. What was left was a folk belief that medieval writers already describe: a corpse could rise, spread disease, and attack the living, and one remedy was to dig it up, break it, and burn the pieces.
Mays's conclusion is quoted on the Southampton page, and his conditional deserves to be kept. The idea that the bones are corpses burned and dismembered to keep them from walking "seems to fit the evidence best." The "if we are right" is not modesty for its own sake. It is the actual status of the claim. The pit is a fact. The burning and the breaking are facts. The revenant explanation is the one left standing after the other two failed. A later reader can reject it. The isotopes and the placement of the cuts will still be there to argue with. An interment that follows the ordinary rite of a churchyard is a different kind of evidence. This pit was not one of those.
What the medieval writers were afraid of
The Southampton account is clear about the belief the bones are being asked to illustrate. In medieval folk belief, a restless corpse was usually put down to a lingering, malevolent life-force in someone who had done evil, or who had made enemies, while alive. Writers of the period describe digging up a corpse like that. The fear was a practical one. The dead were thought to carry disease through the village and to attack the living. That is a burial custom in the strict sense: a second handling of a body already in the ground, carried out by the living for their own protection. It is not a ghost story tacked on by a tour. The village was later abandoned. The belief, if the team is right, was at work while people still lived there.
The same fear turns up in other centuries with other tools. In post-medieval Poland, a sickle across the throat was one way to hold a body down, and the isotope work there also found local people instead of strangers. That cemetery is Drawsko and Pień. In nineteenth-century New England the fear fastened onto tuberculosis, and onto a coffin lid tacked with initials. That panic is JB-55 and Mercy Brown. Wharram Percy is older, and its tools are fire and breakage instead of iron. The pattern the archaeologists are pointing to is the same kind of pattern: a community that did not trust the grave to hold.
A deserted village, and a file with a date
English Heritage's page for the site is a visitor page, not the excavation report. What it confirms is the place: Wharram Percy, a deserted medieval village, in the care of the charity that manages it. The bones are not presented as a spectacle in that listing. The history that matters for this pit is the 2017 paper and the university's summary of the tests. A haunted cemetery, in the later English sense, is often a press story laid over a garden cemetery. Highgate in 1970 has letters to a newspaper. Wharram Percy has a pit, a strontium series, and a sentence from a scientist who will not drop the "if."
The Halloween use of the find is the one Mays already declined to dress up. He called it a dark side of medieval belief, and a reminder that the medieval view of the world was not the same as ours. He did not call it a vampire, and the Southampton account does not need the word. Revenant is enough, and even that is the interpretation that fit, not a label carved in stone. At least ten people ended up in a pit inside the settlement instead of in a row in the churchyard. They had grown up nearby. Someone burned and broke their bones after death. The rest is the sentence he asked the reader to keep conditional.
Sources
- University of Southampton, "New archaeological evidence throws light on efforts to resist 'the living dead,'" 3 April 2017. The 137 bones, at least ten people, the eleventh to fourteenth centuries, the pit in the settlement, the strontium result, the cannibalism test, and Simon Mays's "If we are right." https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2017/04/living-dead.page
- English Heritage, Wharram Percy Deserted Medieval Village. The site is in English Heritage's care. https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/visit/places/wharram-percy-deserted-medieval-village/
- Simon Mays and colleagues, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, published 3 April 2017, as cited by the University of Southampton news release above. The knife marks, burning, and deliberate breakage are described there.